After 14 years, the city of Philadelphia will reconsider Ellen Greenberg casea teacher whose death was suicide in 2011 after she was found with almost two ten stab wounds and covered with bruises. And her father believes investigators should look at Darngulation as the possibility of his daughter.
Greenberg, 27, was found in his kitchen with 20 stab wounds and a knife in the chest with a half -kamet fruit salad at Countertop during the Broken on January 26, 2011, Dr. Marlon Osbourne, initially the murder of Greenberg’s murder in 2011 by murder. He then reversed the course after a meeting with the police behind closed doors and officially judged suicide, according to court records.
Just a week ago, Osbourne retired to the suicide verdict.
“It’s my professional opinion of Ellen’s Maning of Death should be labeled as something other than suicide,” he wrote. “Ever since I issued a modified death certificate, I became aware of additional information that I did not have at the time of issuing a changed death certificate that may have influenced my opinion.”
The death of a teacher with 20 stab wounds to be re -examined while parents agree with the city
Sandee Greenberg was in Philadelphia on Monday, when a settlement was reached with the city in the case of her daughter. (Gavin fish)
Days later, the City of Philadelphia solved a lawsuit with Greenberg’s parents, Dr. Josh and Sande Greenberg, who accused local officials and doctors’ office, including Osbourne for participating in “hidden conspiracy for purposes disguise Ellen’s murder As suicide, “according to legal documents.
“A settlement agreement was reached between the city of Philadelphia and the Ellen Greenberg family,” The Law Department of the City of Philadelphia Confirmed with Fox News Digital. “Settlement conditions include an independent inspection of the autopsy file and explicit renunciation of all requirements that could be submitted as a result of this procedure.”
The city will pay the Greenbergs an undiscovered amount as part of the settlement, for their lawyer, Joseph Podraza, he told Fox News Digital.
“I felt like Ellen proud,” Sandee said with her husband in an interview with Fox News Digital camera.
Follow the true criminal team on x
“Now we have Osbourne, saying that it should not be suicide, the original pathologist who solved the case to the end,” Podraza said.
“And no matter what the city does with him, the key was Osbourne and his check. If they continue to live in the mistake of being suicide, this is the choice that they bring and their credibility will be shot. We hope they will do it The city will do the right thing and also determine this case – the murder. “
Judge nerd by mistake on the “suicide” place where the teacher was found stabbed 20 times
Ellen Greenberg, left, on a undated family photo. (Greenberg family)
At the time of his death, Greenberg sent notifications of federal dates to the wedding with Sam Goldberg, who said he returned home from the gym, broke the door and found the body of his fiancé in their shared apartment in Manayunk, a quiet neighborhood in Philadelphia.
“When Ellen took her own life, she left me confused. She was a wonderful and kind person who had everything for a living. When she died, part of me died with her,” Goldberg said in December in his first public in his first public A statement about Greenberg’s death.
“Mental illness is very real and there are many victims. … I hope and pray that you never lose someone you love as I did from a terrible illness, and then I am accused by unknown and mis -informed people to cause her death.”
Asked if Goldberg was directly in contact with the Greenbergs regarding Ellen’s case, Podraza said he was not.
“There was no communication with himself, nor did he ever turn to us the help or support of our efforts,” Podraza said, adding that nothing has changed since Osbourne revealed his “suicide”.
Master’s fiancé found with 20 stab wounds suggests that led to her ‘suicide’
Ellen Greenberg with his parents, Dr. Josh and Sandee Greenberg. (Greenberg family)
Dr. Josh and Sande Greenberg were in Philadelphia on Monday, when a settlement was reached with the city in the case of their daughter. (Gavin fish)
Greenbergs 20 stab wounds 10 from behind were included, at least one of which could have been applied after being dead, according to court documents.
“No one could do it to himself. That just doesn’t make sense,” said the retired forensic pathologist and medical examiner Dr. Michelle Dupre, she told Fox News Digital.
“One of the first things I always do, most forensic pathologists or medical examiners work in these cases, trying to simulate injuries … I couldn’t take a 10-inch knife and stab in the back. The locations with the corners and all that is described I saw it physically, anatomically impossible. “
Get real -time updates directly to Real crime
“As far as 14 years, I mean, this is awful,” she added, compared to Osbourne’s turn of suicide.
Greenberg was also found covered by bruises at different stages of healing, implying that she had received them over a while, reports an autopsy report.
“This was a passion attack,” Podraza said. “You look at the bruises, you look at the blue to the door, you look at the blue to her wrists and the game of stab stabs. For me, there is no doubt that this was an attack of passion.”
Watch ‘Mister’s Death Mysteries’ on the Fox Nation
Greenberg’s 20 stab wounds included 10 from behind, at least one of which could have been applied after being dead, according to court documents. (Fox News)
Although many wounds have long been in the center of Greenberg’s death, her father shared a new theory about how his daughter may have died.
“I think my daughter was strangled,” Philadelphia told reporters this week, confirmed by Fox News Digital.
“All training and everything I had, you have to consider everything,” said Tom Brennan, who has been privately exploring Greenberg’s death for years for Pennlive. “We have photos of autopsy indicating the neck.
Dupre agreed, adding, “Obviously there are signs of giving.”
Judge tied her fiancé Ellen Greenberg took items from her “suicide” scene before a police search
Old photos by Ellen Greenberg provided by her childhood friend. (Justice for Ellen)
Greenberg’s father claims to be “abused” and that she had injuries on her body in accordance with abuse.
While talking to Fox News Digital after a settlement on Monday, he described in detail what he believed had happened in the moments that led to his daughter’s death.
“Ellen faced her abuser … and it pulled it out of her hand. He hit her on the head. That’s what Gash was. And then he strangled her,” he said. “Suicide is the easiest way to cover up the murder, so that all these 20 stab wounds, even deep on the back of the neck, and those in the chest were part of the concealment.”
Login to get A truly crime newsletter
While Greenberg’s death gets a new look of the city medical examiner for the first time in 14 years, the former Det for murder. Ted Williams told Fox News Digital to believe that “there is a need to determine who killed her.”
“Regardless of whether it was indefinite or murder, further investigation seems to be justified,” Williams said.
Teaching Little Probably “Suicide” was called while the web rust digs in a supervisory video
Ellen Greenberg as a teacher (Ellen Greenberg family)
The Pennsylvanija government Josh Shapiro, who at the time inherited Greenberg’s case after suicide in 2011 as a general lawyer, responded to the new classification of Osbourne during a press conference on Thursday, ABC 27 reported.
Shapiro said his investigation into the Attorney General “pointed to suicide,” adding that it was sufficient to decide if the new determination in Osbourne was sufficient to encourage the case in Osbourne at Osbourne.
“He has to have some evidence with that, not just that one feels different. But surely, if there is any evidence that this medical examiner has discovered – I’m not familiar with that, I’m no longer AG,” Shapiro said. “If they have new evidence, new information, they should share it immediately.”
An independent investigation that the district of District was launched about two years ago after Shapiro and District Attorney General Philadelphia Larry Krasner pulled out from the case.
The Chester District District Office was published in November that “he is not currently unable to move forward with criminal charges”, but Greenberg’s case moved to “inactive” status and left it open for a re -supplement if he obtained new information.
Prosecutors Ellen Greenberg say they can’t prove a crime in ‘suicide’ up to 20 stab wounds
Ellen Greenberg, left, on a undated family photo. (Greenberg family)
Prior to this week’s settlement with the City, the Greenbergs were entangled in legal battles with the Government since the death of their daughter, fighting suicide and citing the “conspiracy” for “the concealment of Ellen’s murder to hide their own investigation”, according to court records.
Now, given Osbourne’s abolition, Podraza says “Criminal investigation should be automatically. “
“We would participate in who will cope with it and how to ensure that it is objective, fair and effective,” he added. “We will not allow only to sit. It’s been 14 years. We intend to cross that target line and keep the one responsible for her murder … responsible.”
Click here to get the Fox News app
“Ellen was a person, a citizen of Philadelphie and Pennsylvania, and she deserves justice,” said Dr. Josh Greenberg.
Philadelphi police He did not immediately respond to the Fox News Digital request for comment. They previously refused to discuss the case, citing a permanent dispute that is ongoing. Goldberg did not immediately respond to the comment.
Michael Ruiz Fox News Digital contributed to this report.
