Steelers fans react as Russell Wilson and Justin Fields give way to Jets QB in bold predictions

On Thursday, Pro Football Talk’s Mike Florio sparked a heated debate among Steelers fans, suggesting that Aaron Rodgers could join Pittsburgh in 2025. The speculation comes from Russell Wilson and Justin Fields are nearing the end of their contracts, and neither guard has cemented a long-term role.

Steelers fans flooded social media with immediate opposition to the idea. The fan reaction highlighted a clear preference for developing current talent over gambling on an aging superstar with recent performance issues.

The debate has gained momentum as Pittsburgh faces increasing pressure to win its first playoff game since 2016. With three straight losses under Wilson, Florio suggested the Steelers might reconsider Rodgers as a short-term solution.

“If/when the Jets fire Rodgers, why wouldn’t the Steelers consider adding him?” wrote Florio.

He emphasized Pittsburgh’s stable environment as a potential attraction, citing “minimal dysfunction, few leaks, strong leadership, continuity and consistency.”

Many fans have expressed skepticism about Aaron Rodgers’ declining performance and potential impact on team dynamics.

“There was a time I would have killed for this. Not anymore man, Rodgers is washed up,” one fan posted on X.

Another warned, “If Tomlin brings in Rodgers, I’m officially on the Fire Tomlin train.”

A third fan added, “Mike wouldn’t put up with Aaron’s thirst to be the main character above the team.”

Some fans gave priority to stability and youth in their answers.

“I have to keep Justin if that’s the case. No question,” one supporter claimed.

Others directed frustration at the leadership, with comments like “I’d Rather Fire Tomlin”

“Now it’s Tomlin who has to go, he just can’t do it in the bigs,” added another.

The relationship between Aaron Rodgers and Mike Tomlin adds a layer to the debate

Aaron Rodgers’ Dec. 17 appearance on the Pat McAfee Show showed his respect for Mike Tomlin’s coaching accomplishments.

“There’s only one Mike Tomlin, first and foremost, and you’ve got to give Mike credit. He’s got special sauce,” Rodgers said, praising Tomlin’s 18-season undefeated streak.

The debate is heating up as Pittsburgh approaches a key playoff crossroads. The Steelers could secure the No. 5 seed and face the Houston Texansor with the help of the Cleveland Browns, potentially host the Los Angeles Chargers.

This postseason performance could determine whether Pittsburgh pursues the veteran like Aaron Rodgers or keeps faith with his current quarterback room.