Check what click on foxbusiness.com.
Miley Cyrus He may have to face music because it seems that the federal judge “probably” refuses his offer to dismiss the copyright lawsuit filed through his single “Flowers”, who accused the singer of copying the hit song by Bruno Mars “when I was your man.”
During the Los Angeles court hearing on Monday, Judge Dean D. Pregerson “repeatedly indicated” that he agreed that the prosecutor, the tempo of music investment, had a legal position to continue with the case, he said Rolling Stone.
In September, Tempo Music Investments filed a lawsuit against Cyrus and several co -defendants, claiming that “flowers” gave “striking similarities” when I was your man “, including” numerous melodic, harmonious and lyrical elements. “
Miley Cyrus accused of copying Bruno Mars in a lawsuit over the song ‘Flowers’
Cyrus lawyers rejected the claims and filed a proposal to reject the lawsuit, claiming that the pace of musical investment, which only owns a fractional share of Mars song that the company bought from one of its writers, Philip Lawrence, around 2020, had no position over “Flowers.”
It seems that the federal judge “probably” rejected the proposal for Miley Cyrus for release after suing for the alleged copying of one of Bruno Mars’s hit songs. (Getty Images / Getty Images)
However, Rolling Stone reported that Prengers seemed to have agreed several times with the arguments of lawyer Tempo Music Investments, Alex Wentbarten.
“There is a deep question of politics before the court. The adoption of the rules he called [Cyrus] he would turn The whole music industry, Indeed, the technological industry, in the ear. The policy behind the author’s rights law enables people freely [sell] Their interests in copyright, “Wentbarten said in court, on the way out.
Pregerson seemed to have pointed to the support of the explanation, noting, “Or if one dies and someone acquires interest through the property. Suddenly he loses the right to carry him out.”
According to Rolling Stone, Pregerson had previously questioned what would motivate anyone to buy a fractional stake in the song “Knowing that they could never implement it” unless they received permission from all co -authors.
“Precisely, honorably,” Wentarten replied. “That’s stupid. If the right does not involve the right to carry out that right, then the right is pointless. You cannot have a rule where if the copyright owner dies, their property is unable to be able to implement that copyright.”
Pregerson did not immediately reach a judgment regarding the proposal to rejection. However, he said he would make a written decision in the coming weeks and months.
The lawsuit claimed that Miley Cyrus’s winner of Grammy “Flowers” achieved “striking similarities” Bruno Mars “What It Your Man” song. (Getty Images / Getty Images)
According to Renou, Nevada, Radio Station Ten Country@97.3, By citing a court transcript, the judge allegedly stated that he was “likely to refuse a request to reject the case” on the basis of believed that prosecutors have “merit”.
Cyrus collected his first set Grammy wins For the record of the year and the best pop solo performance for “Flowers” at the 66th annual awards in February 2024.
Hitmaker “Wrecking Ball” performed a live song during the ceremony, and “Flowers” also deserved the best international honors of the 2024 awards.
“Flowers” has become a sensation overnight, debut on number 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 scale and breaking the board to become the fastest song that has achieved a billion flow on Spotify.
“Adopting the rules he called [Cyrus] The whole music industry, indeed, turned into a technological industry, into the ear. “
The laws of Tempo Music Investments stated: “Any fan of Bruno Mars” When I was your man “knows that Miley Cyrus ” Flowers ‘did not achieve all that success alone’.
“Flowers” duplicates numerous melodic, harmonious and lyrical elements “when I was your man,” including the melodic design of the tone and the order of the verse, bonding of bass, a certain grid of choir, certain theater music elements, lyric elements and specific progression if they are a suit. “
“It is indisputable, based on the combination and number of similarities between two shots,” flowers “would not exist without” when I was your man. “
Court documents include a side comparison of the texts of the two songs. (Lawsuit for temporal music music / foxbusiness)
The lawsuit says “The introductory vocal line from the ‘Flowers’ choir begins and ends on the same chords as the introductory vocal line in the verse’ When I was your man.”
The documents included a lateral representation of the texts from “When I was your man” and “Flowers” to show alleged similarities.
The texts presented in “When I was your man” included “I had to bring you flowers,” “and held your hand,” “I should have given you all my hours” and “take you to every party, because all you wanted to do was dance.”
In the meantime, the texts of “flowers” include “flowers can buy flowers”, “and can hold their own hand”, “talk to you for hours” and “I can dance.”
Mars was not mentioned as a prosecutor in the litigation.
Together with Cyrus, in a lawsuit for the allegedly unauthorized “exploitation” of the song “Flowers”, Gregory Hein and Michael Pollack were included. More accused, along with Sony Music Publishing And Apple, they were additionally appointed in court documents.
Mars hit “When I was your man” was written by singer, Philip Lawrence, Ari Levine and Andrew Wyatt.
Bruno Mars was not appointed prosecutor in a lawsuit. (Theo Wargo / Getty Pictures to Take Academy / Getty Pictures)
After publishing in December 2012, “When I was your man” became a mega-hit. After more than 16 weeks on the Billboard Hot 100, Mars song climbed to number 1 in April 2013.
Click here to read more about Fox Business
Mars also received a Grammy Nomination for Best Pop Solo Performance for Melodius in December 2013, and in 2014 the song won the “most effective song” at the Pop Music Awards hosted by the American Composers Society, Author and Publisher (Ascap).
In May 2021. “When I was your man” she got her 11th platinum certificate.
Miley Cyrus filed a cancellation request in November. (Mohindra/Peacock/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images/Getty Images)
Stone Day, a Greenberg Glusker partner, told Fox Business that the copyright lawsuits are “very common”, but rarely include celebrities. He said Cyrus was named as a defendant because she was one of the “flowers” of the co-writer.
Stone also aspired whether Cyrus would face the difficulties in proving that she and her writer did not plague “when I was your man.”
“The plaintiff will have to prove that “flowers” He broke the copyright for the musical composition “When I was your man,” “he said.” If the parties did not settle before the trial, the trial is likely to include a testimony of how Miley and her associates wrote “Flowers”.
“Both sides usually offer skilled testimonies of trained musicologists about whether they are” flowers “and” when I was your man “significantly similar songs, including comparison of notes and texts,” he explained.
Get a job with Fox on a clicking movement here
Fox Business’ Stephanie Giang Paunon and Tracy Wright contributed to this report.
