Mariah Carey She won a big Wednesday after being charged with copying texts for her hit “All I want for Christmas is you.”
Judge Mónica Ramírez Almadani approved the Carey’s proposal for a concise verdict before the case was on trial, Fox News Digital can confirm.
Carey fought over her Hit Christmas song After the songwriters of the songs accused the R&B pop singer of stealing the text in the appeal for the first time filed in 2023.
Mariah Carey Faced with a $ 20 million lawsuit because of ‘all I want for Christmas is you’
Mariah Carey was approved a summary of the Copyright Commentary on the 2023 Copyright. (Karen Warren/Houston Chronicle via Getty Images)
Andy Stone, the leading vocalist Vince Vance and Valianta, wrote his song-so-called “All I Want for Christmas is” -1989. years. Stone accused Carey and her team copying the “compositional structure of his song”, according to a complaint received by Fox News Digital.
Carey “directly” copied texts from Stone’s 1989 hit, and “Ab
Mariah Carey ‘Queen of Christmas’
Mariah Carey is accused of copying the texts of her hit song “All I want for Christmas is you.” (Terrence Patrick/CBS via Getty Images)
Stone claimed that Carey and her team “undoubtedly” had access to their version “All I want for Christmas is you” Because of its “broad commercial and cultural success”. Stone’s song was drawing on Billboard for years, and his band performed a song during a appearance at the White House in the spring of 1994. – Carey’s song was released the same year.
The performance of the White House was returned by Vince Vance and the Valiana song on the ladder Hot Country Billboard in 1994, according to court documents.
“Carey took advantage of the success of her broken labor,” Stone’s appeal said. “” Everything I want for Christmas is you “has become a ubiquitous part of the popular culture, and Carey’s name has become synonymous with the season.”
As you read? Click here for more news about fun
Mariah Carey posted “Everything I Want for Christmas” in 1994. (Getty Images)
After hearing from two experts for each side, Ramírez Almadani agreed with those from the defense, who said the writers used the usual Christmas clichés that existed before both songs, and that Carey’s song used them differently. She said the prosecutors did not fill the burden, showing that the songs were much similar.
The judge also ordered sanctions against Stone and authority, claiming that the prosecutors filed a frivolous lawsuit and “did not order reasonable efforts to ensure that the factual claims have proof support.” They will also have to pay part of Carey’s legal fees.
Fox News Digital addressed the representatives of Carey for comment.
Click here to sign up for a bulletin for fun
The said to the said to the said Mariah Carey ordered to pay the legal compensation of the musicians. (Photo James Devaney/Wireimage via Getty Images)
Stone’s lawyer, Gerard P. Fox, said he was “disappointed” with the outcome of the UE -the associate press.
Fox claimed that the judges at this level “almost always reject the case of musical copyright and must regret to reverse and get the case of the jury. My client will soon make a decision on whether to regret.
Click here to get the Fox News app
Associated Press contributed to this report.
